Thursday, January 30, 2014

From Up on Poppy Hill

(2011) Directed by Goro Miyazaki; Written by Hayao Miyazaki and Keiko Niwa; Based on a manga by: Chizuru Takahashi and Tetsurô Sayama; Starring: Masami Nagasawa, Jun'ichi Okada and Keiko Takeshita; Available on DVD and Blu-ray

Rating: ****

"You have the terrible period of World War II, and that was followed by chaos. The period we're talking about here is right before economic growth, and that was the brief moment in Japan when people were able to enjoy a relative time of peace and calmness." – Goro Miyazaki (excerpt from Los Angeles Times article, Goro Miyazaki Sets His Own Path in Animation, By Rebecca Keegan)

With the great Hayao Miyazaki announcing his retirement last year for perhaps the last time, what does the future of Studio Ghibli look like?  If I had to base my judgment solely on his son Goro’s previous effort, the ambitious but joyless Tales from Earthsea (yes, I realize I gave it three stars, but mostly for the animation and the attempt.), I would say Ghibli’s prospects weren’t too rosy.   The younger Miyazaki more than redeemed himself, however, with his nostalgic sophomore effort, From Up on Poppy Hill (aka: Kokuriko-Zaka Kara).  The focus is on drama instead of fantasy, taken at a slower pace (think Whisper of the Heart), where characterization prevails over action.  

The story (written in part by Hayao Miyazaki) follows two high school students, Umi Matsuzaki (Masami Nagasawa) and Shun Kazama (Jun'ichi Okada) as they work together to save their fellow students’ clubhouse, the friendship that develops between them in the process. It’s set amidst the backdrop of 1963-era Japan, when the country was still reeling from the devastation of World War II, and preparing for the 1964 Tokyo Olympics.  One of the recurring themes throughout the film is the concept of “out with the old, and in with the new.”  There’s a sense of cautious optimism, as Japan is teetering on the edge of a cultural and economic transformation.  Goro shares his father’s meticulous attention to detail with richly animated sequences, which make this portrait of a society in transition spring to life.  

Umi is the embodiment of resilience and selflessness in the face of uncertainty.  Her mother, who works as an MD, is traveling in America.  She lives in her grandmother’s seaside house with two siblings and several boarders.  Every morning, she carries on the ritual of raising signal flags; a symbolic gesture honoring her father, whose ship was lost at sea when she was a little girl.  She finds a distraction from her household chores when she becomes involved with an effort by some fellow students to save their school’s beloved clubhouse from demolition.  Although she has a shaky beginning with Shun, one of the organizers, they gradually develop a friendship that evolves into something more. As Umi and Shun explore their past, they discover a link between their families that threatens to tear their budding romance apart.   

The third main character of the film is the clubhouse, providing many of the film’s lighter moments. Dusty, splintered and ramshackle, the clubhouse represents old Japan, which most of the students, and paradoxically the older generation, are eager to distance themselves from.  It’s a piece of history, which many are in a hurry to erase, in favor of a new building.  It’s no coincidence that the clubhouse’s most ardent supporters are a dedicated bunch of high school students who were born after World War II.  They represent a reluctance to sublimate the past and let it fade away, a drive to restore balance and harmony by allowing it to co-exist with the present.

Goro Miyazaki spins his tale with warmth and earnestness.  He’s not afraid to slow things down in service of the story – rewarding subsequent viewings with wonderful visual details and character nuances.  After stumbling with Tales from Earthsea, he found his voice with From Up on Poppy Hill, indicating his relative strengths lie in the little dramas, not epic adventures.  We shouldn’t grieve for the elder Miyazaki and his works, but welcome Goro as another worthy director in the acclaimed Studio Ghibli stable.  The future of Ghibli is in good hands.


  1. Great review! I have this one lined up to watch soon. I haven't seen it yet. The subject matter appears quite timely and the animation looks amazing. Nice job!

    1. Thanks Vic! Honestly, I wasn't expecting much from Goro Miyazaki after seeing Tales from Earthsea a while back, but I thought I'd give it a shot. I was pleasantly surprised by its heart and depth. I'd love to hear your thoughts about it as well.